Blog  ·  Wages

Time-Clock Rounding, Shaving, and Edited Punches: When Small Amounts of Time Become Real Money

Most workers glance at their punches and assume the numbers are the numbers. Timekeeping systems, though, are usually configured to round, and supervisors frequently have authority to edit entries after the fact. Rounding is not automatically unlawful under the Fair Labor Standards Act, but it is lawful only under specific conditions. When those conditions are not met, or when time is quietly edited away, the practice becomes an unlawful failure to pay for hours worked.

The rule permits an employer to round punches to the nearest five minutes, tenth of an hour, or quarter hour, provided the practice is neutral. Neutral means the rounding works in both directions and, over a period of time, does not result in a failure to compensate employees for all the time they actually worked. A system that rounds a 7:56 punch forward to 8:00 and an 8:04 punch back to 8:00 is neutral on its face. A system that rounds start times forward and end times backward is not. Neither is a system that rounds only in the employer's favor at one end of the shift, or one that rounds punches to the scheduled shift time regardless of when the employee actually started.

Neutral on paper is not the same as neutral in practice. Many workplaces require employees to clock in several minutes early to be ready at the start of the shift, then round that early time away, while end-of-shift punches happen at or after the scheduled time and get rounded back. The policy reads as two-way rounding, but the actual pattern of punches runs in one direction because the employer's own rules push it there. When the rounding produces a consistent loss over months, it does not satisfy the regulation regardless of how the policy is written.

Editing time records is a separate and more serious problem. A supervisor who deletes punches, changes recorded start and stop times, moves hours from one week into another to avoid overtime, or approves timecards back to scheduled hours rather than actual hours is not rounding. That is altering the record of hours worked, and it violates both the pay requirements and the recordkeeping requirements of the FLSA. Automatic approval systems that default a timecard to the schedule unless the employee objects create the same result.

The numbers are larger than they look. Seven minutes lost per day, five days a week, is 35 minutes a week. Across 50 working weeks that is 29.17 hours a year. For a worker earning $18 an hour, that is $525 a year at straight time, and considerably more when the lost time falls in weeks with more than 40 hours, because those minutes are compensable at one and one-half times the regular rate. Multiply that across a workforce and a small configuration setting becomes a substantial amount of unpaid wages.

Employers are required to keep accurate records of the hours their employees work, and that obligation belongs to the employer rather than the worker. When an employer's records are inaccurate or incomplete, courts permit employees to establish their hours through reasonable estimates and the evidence available to them. Workers who suspect their time is being rounded away or edited should keep their own record of daily start and stop times, photograph or screenshot the clock at punch time when possible, save copies of schedules and approved timecards, and compare punch detail to the hours that appear on the pay stub.

Workers in similar situations may have legal rights under the FLSA. Unpaid overtime and minimum wage claims are generally subject to a two-year statute of limitations, and three years if the employer's conduct was willful. Time limits apply.

← Back to all posts

Think You Are Owed Overtime or Wages?

The call is free and confidential. Tell us what happened and we will tell you whether you have a claim.

Get a Free Case Review Call (713) 868-3388